Dot Hatfield

First Person Limited

  • Subscribe to Dot’s blog
  • Home Page
  • About Dot Hatfield
  • Dot’s Books
    • Worth the Candle
    • Did Anyone Read My Story?
    • An Ordinary Day
    • R.I.P. Emma Lou Briggs
    • To Find a Home
    • The Last To Know
    • Every Day a New Day
  • Contact Dot
To Kill A Mockingbird

To Kill A Mockingbird

April 8, 2012 1 Comment

Last night I watched the American Film Institute’s 50th Anniversary presentation of To Kill a Mockingbird. This was shown on the USA Network with only four well-place commercial breaks.

This is my favorite movie, and possibly the best movie ever made.  An AFI survey a few years ago listed Citizen Kane as the number one film of all time, but I can’t stand Citizen Kane, so I just might be biased.

Earlier last week I also watched (on Netflix) the documentary, Hey Boo: Harper Lee and To Kill a Mockingbird, made in 2010 for the 50th anniversary of the novel.

The book and the movie can almost be reviewed as one, they are that close in plot and dialogue. Harper Lee was a consultant on the movie and much of the original writing from the novel made it into the screenplay.  This happens so seldom it is worth mentioning.

I fell in love with the book 52 years ago when I bought it from the Book of the Month club. Not only did I love the book, everyone did. It later won a Pulitzer Prize.

Today, watching the movie, most agree that no one but Gregory Peck could have played Atticus Finch.  That’s certainly my point of view. However, in casting the part both Spencer Tracy (well maybe) and Rock Hudson (shudder) were considered.  The casting director combed the South for the perfect Scout and Jem, locating newcomers Mary Badham and Philip Alford.

Mary Badham received an Oscar nomination for best supporting actress for her portrayal of Scout (She lost to Patty Duke in The Miracle Worker). She never appeared in another major film production, though she has made a decent living with television work. Philip Alford later won a role as one of James Stewart’s sons in Shenandoah, but since then has had small roles in big movies or vice versa.

Some said To Kill a Mockingbird, both book and movie, rode the wave of the Civil Rights movement to achieve the success it did. Actually, the book seems not so much about race relations as it is about human kindness and respect for others. Atticus gathers Scout in his arms and talks to her about ‘climbing into the other person’s skin and walking around.’ Thus to find understanding and empathy for the new trying-too-hard teacher, the poor kid in class with no lunch money, Boo Radley and Tom Robinson.

The book is now required reading in most junior high and high schools, often initiating discussions about the characters and their motivations.

For whatever reason, Harper Lee never published another novel. I’m sure she was encouraged (hounded?) to write a sequel. That’s a compliment; it means your characters are strong and likable. But how could she craft a story that compared in any way to the one she had already told?

She reportedly started another novel and got bogged down in the research. She told a close friend she had ‘nowhere to go but down.’   She tired of the limelight and declined to give any more interviews.  Even Oprah could not lure Nelle Harper Lee to sit on the couch with her.

To Kill a Mockingbird. Read it or watch it. With my recommendation.

Books I Read in 2011

January 7, 2012 Leave a Comment

Since I’ve had this blog, each January I have listed the books I read the previous year.   Here are 2011’s books with one-sentence synopses.

1. Unlocked by Karen Kingsbury – Christian Fiction. A teenage girl, sensitive to the needs of an autistic classmate, takes a stand against her popular friends to look for a miracle.

2. Witness by Karen Hesse – Young Adult Fiction. Written in blank verse, this is the story of the Ku Klux Klan’s attempt to move into a small town in Vermont. I reviewed this book in January.

3. Blue Like Jazz –  Christian Non-Fiction.  Donald Miller tells of his faith walk and the people he meets along the way.

4. Critic’s Choice by Ira Levin – Play.  The wife of a literary critic for a large New York City newspaper write a mediocre play and manages to get it produced.

5. The Outlander by Gil Adamson – Fiction. A woman running from an abusive husband finds help, comfort and love with a reclusive mountain man in the far reaches of Canada.

6. Wedding Belles by Alan Bailey – Play. Delightful tale about three spinsters who volunteer to provide a wedding for a young girl with no family.

7. True Grit by Charles Portis – Fiction. The classic story of Mattie Ross’ pursuit of her father’s killer.

8. A Million Miles in a Thousand Years by Donald Miller – Christian Non-Fiction. Story of the making of Donald Miller’s book Blue Like Jazz into a movie.

9. Like Dandelion Dust by Karen Kingsbury – Christian Fiction. A couple learn that their five-year-old son’s birth parents plan to sue for custody.

10. The Captain’s Dog by Roland Smith – YA Creative Non-Fiction.  Adventures on the Lewis and Clark Expedition from the point of view of Captain Lewis’ dog.

11. A Short Guide to a Happy Life by Anna Quindlen – Christian Essay. Perspectives on how to lead a life of contentment.

12. The Pilot’s Wife by Anita Shreve – Fiction. When her husband is killed in a plane crash, a widow finds about his secret life, including another family in Europe.

13. Perfect Match by Jodi Picoult – Fiction. A prominent prosecuting attorney kills the priest accused of abusing her child. This book was reviewed here in May.

14. The Trial by Robert Whitlow – Christian Fiction. An attorney with a lot of baggage of his own, takes the case of a young man accused of murdering a young girl. The Trial was reviewed in June.

15. God Came Near by Max Lucado – Christian Motivation. Scripture-based readings about God coming to earth as Jesus.

16. Hotel by Arthur Hailey – Fiction. Plush hotel in New Orleans faces bankruptcy while several sub-plots are taking place.

17. Mosaic by Verna Lee Hinegardner – Poetry. Chapbook by the former Arkansas Poet Laureate.

18. The Helper by Catherine Marshall – Christian Essays. The author shares stories of encounters with the Holy Spirit.

19. Same Kind of Different Than Me by Ron Hall and Denver Moore – Christian Non-Fiction. Story of the unexpected friendship between a homeless man and a wealthy art dealer. This Book was reviewed in August.

20. The Water Seeker by Kimberly Willis Holt – YA Fiction. Life along the Northwest Passage is hard and sometimes tragic for a young boy and his family.

21. Just Like Jesus – Christian Motivation.  Max Lucado writes about Jesus’ attributes and how we can immulate them in our lives.

22. An Uncommon Crusade by Caron Guillo – Christian Fiction. Story of three youth involved in the Children’s Crusade during the 12th Century. This book was reviewed in October.

23. Like a Rock by Steve May – Christian Motivation. Studies on character building from 1 Thessalonians.

24. The Devil in Pew Number Seven by Rebecca Nichols Alonzo – Biography. Minister’s family is persecuted and beset by problems created by an angry church member.

25. A Long Way from Chicago by Richard Peck – YA Fiction.  Two pre-teens travel from Chicago to visit their grandmother in rural Illinois with resulting culture shock.

26. House Rules by Jodi Picoult – Fiction. Teen age boy with Asberger’s Syndrome is accused of murdering his social skills mentor.

27. Near to the Heart of God by Robert J. Morgan – Christian Devotional. Daily readings based on a connection with favorite Christian hymns.

An Uncommon Crusade by Caron Guillo

An Uncommon Crusade by Caron Guillo

October 26, 2011 2 Comments

Author Caron Guillo says An Uncommon Crusade is a work of fiction based on a mix of fact and legend.

The setting for this story is the Children’s Crusade of 1212, when thousands of children were released by their parents to follow 12-year-old Nicholas of Cologne on a crusade to Jerusalem. The group is largely dependent on the generosity of the townspeople as they travel through small hamlets and larger cities preparing to cross the Alps.

Illness, accidents and other misfortunes plague the group as it makes its arduous trek through the mountains. When they reach Genoa, the crusade fails and the story continues  to follow the three main characters.  Hugo, Simon and Elizabeth, teens who each have their own reasons for following Nicholas: searching for faith, forgiveness, or adventure.

As with most quests, there is much heartache along the way as the friends are separated by death, slavery and tragic circumstances. Though this is not marketed as a historical novel (the genre is Christian fiction) the extensive research that went into the writing of this novel makes it ring true to this particular period of history.

Caron Guillo is a former world history teacher from Texas, who became interested in the Children’s Crusades and chose this setting for her book.  She has crafted a story that is gripping and emotional.

I met Caron at an event introducing this book, so I have one of the early editions. Since that day, An Uncommon Crusade has won the 2011 Next Generation Indie Award for Religious Fiction and received a new cover design. This novel is available at Barnes and Noble and Amazon.com.  Read more about Caron Guillo at her website www.caronguillo.com

Same kind of different as me

Same kind of different as me

August 14, 2011 Leave a Comment

This book is by Ron Hall and Denver Moore, published by Thomas Nelson.  This is the true story of the unlikely friendship between a homeless black man and a wealthy art dealer from Fort Worth. It’s also the story of Deborah Hall, Ron’s wife, a Christian who was called — driven — to minister to homeless persons in the poorest section of the city. One day while volunteering at the Union Gospel Mission, Debbie nudged Ron to reach out to Denver, who had wandered in for a free meal.

Leading up to this moment, Denver tells us how he came to be homeless on the streets of Fort Worth and Ron relates his journey to become one of the richest men in Texas.

Though the friendship begins at Debbie’s urging, it develops into a deep and supportive relationship.  Then, Deborah is diagnosed with cancer and dies after a short battle with the disease. We all are left to wonder why this happens when someone is doing so much good in the world and living a life devoted to Christ. Denver, though crushed himself, is able to offer comfort, spiritual wisdom and insight to Ron during this time.  Together they vow that the work Deborah started will continue.

Same Kind of Different as Me was on the New York Times Bestseller List in 2008 and has since been added to many high school reading lists, a fact I find surprising for a story about the Christian faith.

Denver and Ron are sill friends and continue to minister to people who need to experience God’s love. Denver says at the end of the book, “So, in a way, we is all homeless — just workin our way toward home.”

For more information about the book and authors visit samekindofdifferentasme.com

The Trial

The Trial

June 11, 2011 1 Comment

This novel was loaned to me by my sister, who probably picked it up in a flea market or used book store.  Written by Robert Whitlow and published in 2001 by Word Books, the genre is Christian Mystery.

A young man, Pete Thompson, is accused of murder but has no recollection of anything that happened the night of the crime.  The parents of the murdered girl are wealthy enough to hire a special prosecutor to insure a conviction, though most of the evidence is circumstantial.  “Mac” McLain, a local lawyer, is appointed by the court to defend the young man. His work is cut out for him since Pete can not assist in his defense.  His time in jail becomes a journey of faith for Pete.

A prayer group from the Presbyterian Church commits to pray for everyone involved in the trial and that the truth about what happened would be revealed.  The defense attorney, Mac, has no faith that such activity will help. His belief seems to be that once God finished creating the earth He got rather bored with it and now takes no hand in what happens here.  Mac has plenty of baggage of his own that needs healing but he puts that aside as he tries to do the best for his client in this court room drama.

Whitlow does a good job of keeping us guessing about the real murderer, using red herrings to lead us off in other directions. I was completely surprised, figuring it out only a couple of sentences before the denouement.

In 2010, The Trial was made into a movie starring Matthew Modine and Robert Forster.  I plan to watch it later.  I’m interested in how Hollywood handled the Christian theme that ran through the story. I notice on Amazon that there is a “movie version” of the book and wonder if it’s a re-write of the original.

Robert Whitlow’s latest book, The Water’s Edge, will come out in August. Check out his website www.robertwhitlow.com to see all his titles.

To Find A Home

To Find A Home

May 28, 2011 1 Comment

“Eleven years and two months old and I find out I’m adopted.”

So starts the story of Becca Lucas and her quest to find her birth parents, specifically to ask them WHY. Why did they give her up for adoption?

This story is set in the 60s and 70s when it was not unusual for adoption to be a secret. Adoptees who wanted to find their birth parents were met with resistance.

As Becca matures into a young adult her primary focus remains the same. How this obsession influences her life choices is the basis of the story in To Find a Home.

I will be signing copies of this novel today at Hastings Books in Searcy, 2:00 pm -4:00 pm.  Books are also available at Amazon.com and of course from the back seat of my car. Email me at dot@dothatfield.com.

Perfect Match

May 22, 2011 Leave a Comment

Jodi Picoult does her usual good job with the sensitive and timely issue of child sexual abuse by clergy. And (as usual) I can find very little to critique.

When five year old Nathaniel stops talking, his parents cannot imagine why until, in the psychiatrists office, he acts out a scenario of sexual abuse.  His mother, Nina, is a prosecuting attorney who specializes in family, child custody and abuse cases. She knows how hard it will be to identify the offender and bring him to justice.  Nina is a protagonist that is not entirely likable and the author acknowledges this in the interview in the back of the book.  Nina is fiercely protective of her child, often without being clear on what he really needs (someone to LISTEN).

This story was published in 2002, probably at the height of the allegations against several Catholic priests.  Picoult does a good job of showing Nina’s confusion about her faith, in light of  what the church has always taught and what has happened to her child.  The author works with two first person narrators – Nina and Nathaniel. Other points of view from minor characters are brought out in third person. Though she moves from one POV to another with the aid of spacing and asterisks and a different font for Nathaniel’s voice, sometimes it is a bit confusing as to whose head we are in.  But overall this is a good way to let the reader know where everyone is coming from.

When Nathaniel gives the name of his offender, Nina shoots the priest at his arraignment. (This is not a spoiler. It is told in the prologue.) There follows good information of how the court system works, on DNA and the exploration of feelings toward a friend/wife/mother who would do this.  The surprise twist at the end is very “Picoult” and good fodder for a book discussion group.

From a Writer’s Heart

From a Writer’s Heart

March 13, 2011 2 Comments

I love books. I own many books. I have full bookcases in the guest room, the upstairs entry, the living room and two in the hall.  I don’t have room for a book shelf in my room, so I stack odd titles on the table near my bed.  There are texts arranged “attractively” on the stairs and other spots throughout the house. Once I own a book, I have a difficult time turning loose of it. Oh, I can pass it on to a friend or relative, someone I know will give it a good home, but when it comes to putting a copy in a yard sale, there is some separation anxiety involved. Last time he visited, my son Steve asked if I had ever seen the reality TV show “Hoarders.” I told him to mind his own business.

Even though I have plenty of books and haven’t yet read them all, each time I visit a flea market or thrift store I am drawn to the shelves of fiction and non-fiction. Thus my discovery at the new Goodwill Store in Cabot, Arkansas.  From their limited selection I picked up Anna Quindlen’s A Short Guide to a Happy Life. Then I saw a colorful book that looked familiar . . . ah, yes, I have that book . . . it’s a journal!

I pulled it off the shelf – Reflections From a Mother’s Heart – A Family Legacy for Your Children. My daughter, Kathy, had given me an copy of this journal of prompts about ten years ago.  Each page contains an open response question: Who gave you your name and why? Describe your childhood home. What was the hardest thing you ever had to do?  These guides are intended to bring out “Your life story in your own words.”

I opened the book. “Rita” had filled out the “Personal Portrait” page – names of parents, siblings and children, likes and dislikes. I closed the cover. I shouldn’t be reading this. I opened again and  flipped the pages. Several had writing; the journal less than half complete.

How did this volume of Rita’s private thoughts come to be in the Goodwill Store? Did she become discouraged and decide to discard it unfinished? If that were the case, I can see putting it in the shredder perhaps. Maybe Rita died and there was no one who cared to keep her written thoughts even for sentimental reason. But, again, why not use the shredder rather than put her words out for the idly curious to read? Maybe the book is here by accident – inadvertently put in a box of other books to be recycled and resold.

I brought the journal home. Though the clues are scant, I’m of a mind to try to find a family member who wants this journal, values Rita’s words. But, if I discover the book did not arrive at the Goodwill Store by accident, that it was carelessly tossed away with the bulk of Rita’s personal belongings, how will I feel about that? I don’t know. I think I will be sad.

In the meantime: Rest in peace, Rita. Your journal is safe with me.

« Previous Page
Next Page »

My Books

  • Worth the Candle
  • Did Anyone Read My Story?
  • An Ordinary Day
  • R.I.P. Emma Lou Briggs
  • To Find a Home
  • The Last To Know
  • Every Day a New Day

POST Topics

  • Living my Life
  • Movies
  • Reading List
  • Somewhat Current Events
  • Television
  • Too General to Define
  • Writing

Pages of Interest

  • Reflections from Dorothy’s Ridge
  • Charles Prier
  • Pat Laster
  • Freeda Nichols
  • White County Creative Writers
  • The Looking Glass
  • Talya Tate Boerner

Recent Comments

  • Linda on Between All Hallows Eve and Christmas
  • Amber Bass on Between All Hallows Eve and Christmas
  • Dorothy Johnson on Between All Hallows Eve and Christmas
  • Gary on Don’t Worry
  • Linda Quade on Don’t Worry

Post Archives

© 2017 Dot Hatfield.